How to Choose the Best Wifi Thermostat (2024)

by Gongo Smart Admin

Is a Wi-Fi enabled thermostat right for you?

How to Choose the Best Wifi Thermostat (1)Family Handyman

A Wi-Fi thermostat connects to your home's wireless Internet service and lets you remotely check and change the temperature in your home from an app on your smartphone or tablet. When Wi-Fi thermostats first came out, the buyers were mainly snowbirds who wanted an alert if their furnace conked out while they were down south. That's not the case anymore. In fact, Wi-Fi thermostats are quickly becoming standard equipment for new homes. If you're considering upgrading your thermostat to a high-tech Wi-Fi version, here's what you need to know.

By the DIY experts of The Family Handyman Magazine

6 reasons you might want to get Wi-Fi thermostats

How to Choose the Best Wifi Thermostat (2)

Is a Wi-Fi smart thermostat right for you?

  1. TravelIf you live in a cold climate and travel, you should definitely get Wi-Fi smart thermostats to keep tabs on your furnace when you’re away. In cold weather, a furnace breakdown can endanger pets and plants and lead to frozen pipes and catastrophic water damage.
  2. Easy programmingSetback thermostats save energy but are a pain to program. If programming your current setback thermostat drives you nuts, you’ll like the ease of programming a Wi-Fi unit. Just download the app and enter the temps and times on your phone or tablet.
  3. No need to reprogram when your schedule changesIf you have a variable schedule, a typical setback thermostat won’t adjust to your changes. But learning Wi-Fi thermostats will. It detects when you’re home and away, learns your schedule and calculates a setback scheme to match your routine. Some learning thermostats also offer a ‘geofence’ feature that tracks the location of your smartphone and operates your setback settings based on when you enter or leave a geographic radius around your home. So, for example, it can crank up the heat when you’re returning from a trip and are a few miles from home.
  4. Change the temp from anywhereFeeling too hot or cold but don’t want to get out of bed or your comfy lounger to adjust the temp? Just reach for your smart device, pull up the app and knock the temp up or down a few degrees. You can also warm up the house just before you arrive there-Wi-Fi thermostats offer the convenience of adjusting temps from wherever you are.
  5. Monitor your HVAC systemSome Wi-Fi thermostats monitor the efficiency of your heating/cooling system and alert you if the efficiency drops because of a dirty air filter, clogged evaporator or condenser coils, low refrigerant charge, or other problem.
  6. They’re cool!You can get units that display your digital photos, play your tunes, change color to match your walls, display the outside temperature or work with multiple sensors. If any of these features sound good, read on to find out if a Wifi thermostat will work in your home.

The hottest Wi-Fi smart thermostats

How to Choose the Best Wifi Thermostat (3)

Ecobee

TheEcobee3 Thermostatsolves the No. 1 consumer complaint—that a room or level is always too hot or cold. The unit comes with a separate wireless sensor to install on that troublesome level or cold room. The sensor communicates with the main thermostat and adjusts heating or cooling to maintain a comfortable setting near the remote sensor. The unit also monitors system performance and alerts you if the furnace or A/C isn’t keeping up with the demand.

There are dozens on the market ranging in cost from $110 to $300. You’ll find some at home centers, but begin your shopping online to get a full picture of what’s available.

DIY install Wi-Fi smart thermostat?

Professional thermostat installation runs about $75 if you combine the installation with a regular seasonal checkup. We think that’s a bargain. But if you feel comfortable wiring it yourself, you can save the money. Just make sure you shut off the power and double-check your wiring to be sure wires don’t touch at the terminals. If you’re not careful, you can easily burn up a transformer or blow the circuit board’s main fuse. In that case, the service call will cost more than what you saved by installing it yourself.

Wiring issues & solutions

A common (‘C’) wire provides a return electrical path (like a neutral in a 110-volt electrical system) so the thermostat can get power 24/7. If you don’t have a ‘C’ wire at the thermostat, you have two options: Buy a Wi-Fi thermostat that doesn’t require one (it’ll say ‘No C wire required’ in the specs), or install a four-to-five wiring adapter. The ‘No C wire’ style works well in most applications. But if you don’t run the heat or A/C often, the batteries may wear down quickly.

If the main circuit board on your furnace or A/C has a ‘C’ terminal, install a four-to-five wiring adapter to get 24-hour power to the new thermostat. One choice is the Add-a-Wire, No. ACC-0410, fromsupplyhouse.com.

Three things to check

  1. Test your Wi-Fi signal— You must have a strong Wi-Fi signal at the thermostat location. Stand next to your existing thermostat and stream a video on your smartphone or tablet. If it streams smoothly, your Wi-Fi signal is adequate for a thermostat.
  2. Check the wiring—Turn off power to the furnace and A/C and pop the thermostat off the base plate. If you find two thick wires, you probably have 220-volt electric heat, and a Wi-Fi thermostat won’t work. If you have skinny 18-gauge wires, you have a low-voltage system, and it’ll probably work with a Wi-Fi thermostat. Next, look for a wire attached to the ‘C’ terminal. If you find it, any Wi-Fi thermostat will work. If not, you’ll have to buy a ‘No C wire required’ thermostat or install a wiring adapter (see ‘Wiring Issues and Solutions,’ above). And, if your existing thermostat displays the outside temperature or allows you to adjust the settings on your humidifier, it’s probably a digital unit, and an analog Wi-Fi unit won’t work without professional rewiring.
  3. Determine the needs of your heating and cooling system—You’ll need to know what type of system is in your home and how many stages of heating and cooling it has so you can buy a thermostat to match. If you don’t know the specs on yours, find the unit’s model number (usually on a plate inside the cover panel) and look for the specs online, or call the installer and ask.

Install a Wi-Fi thermostat without rewiring

If you’ve checked into installing a Wifi thermostat but discovered your house doesn’t have a common ‘C’ wire, here’s a workaround. Buy a four-to-five wire adapter. The adapter provides a ‘C’ connection using whichever wire isn’t in use at the time. Install the control box inside the furnace and connect it as shown here. Then install the diode device up at the new thermostat. Once all the wires are connected to the base plate, push the excess wires and diode inside the wall cavity.

Back to News

Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device

How to Choose the Best Wifi Thermostat (2024)

FAQs

How do I know which Wi-Fi thermostat to buy? ›

Factors to consider when comparing different models include design, compatibility with your heating and cooling systems and C-wire (common wire) requirements. A C-wire is the wire that connects to your HVAC system to provide a smart thermostat with continuous power. C-wires are required on most smart thermostats.

How do I choose a wireless thermostat? ›

Four main things to consider before purchasing a smart thermostat are Compatibility, Price, Installation and Connectivity.

How do I know what thermostat to get? ›

How to Choose a Thermostat
  1. Decide whether you're interested in a non-connected programmable thermostat or a smart thermostat. ...
  2. Consider your HVAC system. ...
  3. Scope out your wiring. ...
  4. Consider your home's aesthetics. ...
  5. A Word About Installation.
Jul 19, 2022

What is the difference between a smart thermostat and a Wi-Fi thermostat? ›

A smart thermostat can learn and make decisions for you. A smart thermostat, just like a Wi-Fi thermostat, can be controlled by a connected device, such as your cell phone, via an app. Wi-Fi thermostats, however, don't have the ability to learn from your usage.

What is the easiest wireless thermostat to install? ›

Google Nest Thermostat E

The Nest Thermostat E is much simpler to install than our Nest thermostat top pick. The smart module, known as a Heat Link E, isn't wired into your boiler.

Can you replace any thermostat with a smart thermostat? ›

The answer is yes; a smart thermostat can replace a regular one. However, the installation becomes more complex in certain situations. For example, newer homes have a C-wire (common wire) in them, while many older ones don't. Most smart thermostats require a C-wire.

Can I replace my thermostat with a Wi-Fi thermostat? ›

Yes, Home Depot's local, licensed heating and cooling professionals can replace your home thermostat with a new energy efficient smart thermostat.

Are all wireless thermostats compatible? ›

Not all smart thermostat models are compatible with all boilers, so it can't be said that they all connect the same way. Still, the process involved in setting up each type of wireless thermostat is similar.

Do you need special wiring for a Wi-Fi thermostat? ›

Most smart thermostats today that are Wi-Fi enabled or have a color touch screen may require constant power through a thermostat C wire.

What are recommended thermostat settings for home? ›

Recommended Thermostat Settings for Sleeping
  • 65 °F in winter.
  • 78 °F in summer.
  • 65 °F when it's cool and 78 °F when it's warm during spring and fall.
Jun 15, 2021

What is a common problem with thermostat? ›

The Thermostat Is Dirty

Thermostats, like many other electrical appliances, will malfunction if they're allowed to get too dirty. Dirt, dust, and debris can pose problems for both electrical and mechanical components, causing your thermostat to fail.

Is there a downside to smart thermostats? ›

Smart Thermostats Can Be Expensive: The cost of a normal digital thermostat can be as low as $30.00 but many smart thermostats can be a bit more expensive. Smart thermostats range anywhere between $100 to $250 or more. This prohibitive cost can be a big barrier to entry for some consumers.

What happens if Wi-Fi goes down with smart thermostat? ›

In simple terms, your HVAC system continues to run despite the lack of a Wi-Fi connection. How does this work? Most thermostats will maintain the current settings when the internet goes down. However, you might not be able to change or readjust the temperature settings remotely.

Is smart thermostat really worth it? ›

Smart thermostats are a nifty way to control your heating on the go from your phone, tablet or other device. They're touted as a great way to save cash, but they're not cheap – so whether one will save you money depends on how you use it and what type of home you have.

Does it matter what thermostat I buy? ›

Know Your Equipment & Your Wiring

Not all thermostats are compatible with existing HVAC systems, especially smart thermostats! Some thermostats work only with furnaces and air conditioners, for example. Others may be designed to monitor heat pumps or multiple-stage heating and cooling systems.

How do I upgrade my Wi-Fi thermostat? ›

This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
  1. Turn Off Your HVAC System. ...
  2. Pop Off the Faceplate. ...
  3. Remove the Backplate. ...
  4. Add a C-Wire (Optional) ...
  5. Use the New Backplate as a Template. ...
  6. Reconnect the Wires. ...
  7. Install the New Faceplate. ...
  8. Connect the Thermostat to WiFi.
Oct 10, 2023

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 6344

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.